New Free video audit for tradies. No cost, no obligation.
Check my site
Leads

Is hipages worth it? How to work out your real cost per job

A simple way for Australian tradies to compare lead sites like hipages and Oneflare with getting jobs from Google, using your own numbers.

Lead sites such as hipages, Oneflare and ServiceSeeking can fill a diary fast. They can also quietly become your most expensive way to win work. The only way to know is to measure cost per job you actually win, not cost per lead.

This guide doesn’t tell you what any platform charges, because pricing and plans change. It gives you a way to work out your own number.

Why cost per lead is the wrong number

A lead isn’t a job. On shared-lead platforms, the same customer may be contacting several businesses at once. Some leads are tyre-kickers, some are outside your area, and some never answer.

What matters is:

Cost per job won = total spent on the platform ÷ number of jobs you won from it

Work out your numbers

Take the last three months. You’ll need:

Number Where to find it
Total spent Subscription and lead fees from your invoices
Leads received Your account on the platform
Quotes sent Your quoting software or job notes
Jobs won Your invoices
Average invoice value Total invoiced from those jobs ÷ jobs won

Then calculate:

  • Win rate = jobs won ÷ leads received
  • Cost per job won = total spent ÷ jobs won
  • Marketing cost as a share of revenue = total spent ÷ total invoiced from those jobs

Worked example

These figures are made up to show the maths, not real platform prices.

An electrician spends $1,200 over three months and gets 60 leads. They quote 30 and win 12 jobs. Those jobs average $650.

  • Win rate: 12 ÷ 60 = 20%
  • Cost per job won: $1,200 ÷ 12 = $100
  • Revenue from those jobs: 12 × $650 = $7,800
  • Marketing cost: $1,200 ÷ $7,800 ≈ 15% of revenue

Whether 15% is good depends on your margins. For small, low-margin jobs it can eat most of the profit. For a switchboard upgrade or air-con install it can be fine.

The cost you don’t see on the invoice

Time. If you spend 20 minutes on each lead (calling, quoting, following up), 60 leads is 20 hours. Put a value on that time and add it to your cost.

What you’re not building

Every dollar spent on a lead site rents a customer. When you stop paying, the leads stop. Money spent on your own Google profile, reviews and website builds something that keeps working, and repeat customers find you directly rather than through a platform.

That doesn’t mean you should quit lead sites. They’re useful when:

  • you’re new and need work this month
  • you’re testing a new area or service
  • your diary has gaps

They’re less useful when they’ve become your main source of work and your win rate is low.

Compare with Google

Do the same calculation for jobs that came from Google Maps, your website or Google Ads. For that you need to know where each job came from. Ask every new customer “How did you find us?” and write it down, or use call tracking.

If your own channels win jobs for less, shift spend gradually toward them, and keep the lead site for quiet weeks.

Next step

If you don’t know how many jobs come from Google, start there. Our free video audit shows why the top three tradies in your suburb are getting calls ahead of you, and what to fix first.

Check your website free

See what’s stopping homeowners calling you: mobile speed, tap-to-call, page titles, licence number and more. Results on screen, no sign-up.

Or get a free video audit for your suburb →

Check my site free